Apply now
Case Study: Venture Capital

Building executive leverage inside a scaling venture capital firm

A mission-driven venture capital firm searched for nearly a year to find a chief of staff who could match their speed, intellectual rigor, and executional demands. Vannin [now the Chief of Staff Association] engaged with a disciplined, outbound-led approach, screened nearly 450 candidates, and delivered a high-calibre hire who fit seamlessly with the Founding General Partner.

Challenges

A mission-driven venture capital firm operating at the intersection of economic mobility, rigorous research, and hands-on company building, was deploying its $100M Fund III and expanding its venture incubation efforts. The Founding General Partner required a Chief of Staff capable of matching the firm’s speed, intellectual rigor, and executional demands.Prior to engaging Vannin [now the Chief of Staff Association], the firm had searched independently for nearly one year without success. The challenge was not a lack of candidates, but the rarity of individuals who could simultaneously demonstrate:
  • Exceptional intellectual horsepower and analytical acumen
  • Strong judgment, adaptability, and executional excellence in fast-paced environments
  • A personality and working style aligned with a high-performing, entrepreneurial Principal

Solution

Vannin [now the Chief of Staff Association] was engaged for an executive search, recognizing the need for a disciplined, persistent, and highly targeted approach. Vannin delivered through:
  • Rigorous, outbound-led sourcing beyond traditional candidate pools, targeting high-caliber operators across management consulting, investing, and mission-driven organizations
  • Deep candidate screening focused on analytical rigor, executional track record, and real-world problem-solving ability
  • Ongoing calibration with the Venture Partner, refining both technical requirements and the interpersonal dynamics critical to success with the Founding General Partner
  • Structured weekly check-ins to maintain alignment, momentum, and decision clarity throughout the process
  • Extensive market coverage, speaking with nearly 450 candidates and advancing 21 to shortlist in a highly competitive talent landscape
  • Integration of Predictive Index™ (PI) assessments to provide a data-backed view of candidates’ work styles, motivations, and communication preferences – enabling a more precise evaluation of partnership fit and long-term success

Results

The search resulted in a high-caliber Chief of Staff whose background and working style aligned closely with the client’s needs. The candidate brought deep analytical rigor and executional strength from her time at a top-tier global strategy firm, where she consistently ranked among top performers. Following consulting, she earned dual graduate degrees from leading institutions and transitioned into impact investing, with experience evaluating 100+ early-stage companies across climate, healthcare, and education. Her combination of strategic horsepower, operational ownership, and collaborative working style makes her a strong fit for the firm’s fast-paced, hands-on model.The client cited Vannin [now the Chief of Staff Association]’s persistence, high level of service, quality of the hire and the use of Predictive Index™ assessments as key differentiators, enabling confidence in both performance and long-term partnership fit.

Testimonial

We knew going into this search that it was going to be a difficult one. In fact, I often joked with people that I was looking for a unicorn. I have to say that in my 30 years of leadership I’ve not had a lot of luck with search firms so I came into this relationship skeptical. Vannin [now the Chief of Staff Association] really delivered. Their persistence was unmatched. Months into the search, when most firms would have gotten discouraged and less active, Vannin doubled down. I could see their efforts and energy ramping up until we found THE ONE. Special shout out to their COO Emily who stepped in when our rep went out on leave and got us over the finish line!
Venture Partner

Ready to accelerate your growth?

Get in touch

Talent enquiry